An American Pickle

POSITIVES…

  • The man from the past in modern times story is a likeable premise.

  • Gimmick of having Seth Rogen playing against himself works pretty well.

  • Tonally, I appreciated the mix of silliness and melancholy.

  • The opening scene in the 1800s that is completely shown in 4x3 aspect ratio, is absolutely amusing and oh so charming.

  • I like where the jokes that spawned from the Twitter plot line went.

  • As idiotic as the movie can get, I felt like it’s heart was in the right place.

NEGATIVES…

  • That opening scene that I liked a lot? It’s the best scene of the movie. Nothing else tops that.

  • The whole contrasting themes between modern sensibilities versus the working hard values of an older generation hits you over the head a little too much.

  • There’s a huge plot turn that drives the rest of the movie, that I honestly wished it didn’t go there.

  • Some absurd illogical plot points that really pushes your suspension of disbelief.

P.S….

loveditenjoyedit LIKED IT itsokayitsmehitsterrible

An American Pickle - Watch It On HBO MAX